Coin shops & coin dealers in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
10 hand-verified dealers, ranked by review volume. See who's NGC-authorized, who buys collections, and who specializes in what — before you walk in.
10
Verified dealers
1
NGC-authorized
4.7★
Avg Google rating
1,497
Google reviews
Filter by what you need
Gold Rush Pittsburgh
2830 W Liberty Ave #2
4.9(489)
(724) 712-0914
Banner Coin Exchange Inc
404 Smithfield St
4.8(284)
(412) 261-5696
Diamond & Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh
1112 Freeport Rd
5.0(264)
(412) 408-3470
Pittsburgh Gold & Diamonds Buyers - Cash for Gold & Gift Cards
2936 W Liberty Ave
4.5(177)
(412) 563-7777
Olevian Numismatic Rarities
5833 Ellsworth Ave
4.7(120)
(412) 900-2646
Cybercoins.net, Inc.
2927 W Liberty Ave
4.7(42)
(412) 531-3100
Elemetal
703 Parkway View Dr
5.0(42)
(412) 467-0700
Harold B. Weitz, Inc.
6315 Forbes Ave #122
4.3(40)
(412) 521-1879
Eye Buy Gold Silver
25 N Sprague Ave
4.8(39)
(412) 883-0055
Dane C. Olevian Numismatic Rarities, L.L.C.
17th and Smallman Street
(844) 667-2646
Coin dealers in other Pennsylvania cities
Buying & selling coins in Pittsburgh: common questions
Is there a major coin show near Pittsburgh?
Yes — the Pennsylvania Association of Numismatists (PAN) holds large coin shows every May and October at the Monroeville Convention Center just east of Pittsburgh, drawing around 250 dealers with free admission. It's one of the biggest recurring shows in the region and a great place to compare offers before buying or selling.
Which Pittsburgh coin dealers are well regarded?
This directory lists 10 hand-verified Pittsburgh dealers. Banner Coin Exchange has been trading since 1976 and carries a strong review history, Olevian Numismatic Rarities specializes in collector coins, and Gold Rush Pittsburgh has one of the highest review counts in the area for gold buying.
Where should I sell coins versus gold in Pittsburgh?
For collectible and rare coins, an established numismatic shop like Banner Coin Exchange or Olevian is the better fit. For scrap gold and bullion, high-volume gold buyers such as Gold Rush Pittsburgh handle those at spot-based pricing. Matching the shop to what you're selling — and getting a second quote — gets you the best number.
How do I check what my coins are worth before selling in Pittsburgh?
Separate melt value from collectible value. Our silver and gold melt-value calculators give you a live-price baseline for bullion and common silver in seconds; for rare coins, get quotes from a couple of the hand-verified dealers here or bring them to a PAN show in Monroeville for multiple opinions at once.