Coin shops & coin dealers in Fort Myers, Florida
12 hand-verified dealers, ranked by review volume. See who's NGC-authorized, who buys collections, and who specializes in what — before you walk in.
12
Verified dealers
2
NGC-authorized
4.5★
Avg Google rating
416
Google reviews
Filter by what you need
The Coin and Jewelry Exchange
12680 McGregor Blvd Ste 4
4.8(198)
(239) 209-2051
Gulfcoast Coin & Jewelry
14181 South Tamiami Trail Suite #110
4.2(134)
(239) 939-5636
Executive Bullion
12995 S Cleveland Ave #139a
4.4(62)
(239) 374-2218
Eagle's Rare Coins of SW florida
4135 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd Booth Yellow 47
5.0(13)
(239) 445-9028
Numismatic Classics Inc.
12331 TOWNE LAKE DR STE 8
4.1(9)
(239) 313-5687
Gannon's Antiques and Art Center
16521 S Tamiami Trl
(239) 427-0616
Gold Pros Edison Mall
4125 Cleveland Ave, Ste 1370
(239) 910-5297
Larry's Pawn Shop - Fort Myers Shores
14120 Palm Beach Blvd
(239) 690-0111
Mikey's Comics
17240 S Tamiami Trl, Ste 1
(239) 333-8347
Record Trader 1
3091 Cleveland Ave
(239) 337-4330
Regional Real Estate Appraisal Service
Fort Myers, FL 33912
(845) 786-7374
VanPelt Jewelers
12377 S Cleveland Ave, Ste 14
(239) 275-7300
Coin dealers in other Florida cities
Buying & selling coins in Fort Myers: common questions
How active is the coin scene in Fort Myers?
More active than its size suggests. This directory lists 12 hand-verified Fort Myers coin dealers, and the Fort Myers Coin Club bills itself as Southwest Florida's largest — it meets on the third Thursday of each month at the Masonic Lodge on Metro Parkway and hosts a monthly coin show there through the season.
Which Fort Myers coin shops are well established?
Gulfcoast Coin & Jewelry has been trading since 1970, making it the oldest name in our Fort Myers listings, and The Coin and Jewelry Exchange carries one of the area's strongest review histories. Executive Bullion (established 2007) focuses on the bullion side.
Is there a monthly coin show in Fort Myers?
Yes — the Fort Myers Coin Club runs a recurring show at the Masonic Lodge, 10868 Metro Parkway, typically 9am to 3pm. Local shows like this are the easiest way to compare several dealers' offers in one visit before buying or selling.
Do Fort Myers dealers buy gold and silver bullion?
Yes, alongside collectible coins — Executive Bullion and several others handle bullion directly. Because offers track the live spot price, check the day's price before selling; our gold and silver melt-value calculators give you a quick baseline to judge a Fort Myers offer against.